What’s the Difference between the FAFSA and the CSS Profile?

Are you a high schooler or parent of a high school student applying for financial aid? If so, you may be wondering what the difference is between the FAFSA and the CSS Profile — we’ll break it all down.

Introduction

If you’re applying to college and want to be considered for financial aid, then you’ve probably been told to file the FAFSA and/or the CSS Profile. But many students and their parents are left wondering what the difference actually is between the two and what is required to get the maximum possible benefit.

We’ll break down everything you need to know about the two forms and how you can maximize your financial aid package during the college admissions process.

FAFSA vs. CSS Profile at a Glance

The Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA®) is a form that is free to fill out and allows students to apply for financial aid for college, career school, or graduate school. This form, which is provided by the U.S. Department of Education and used by nearly all U.S. colleges and universities, is for “any student, regardless of income, who wants to be considered for federal, state, and school financial aid programs,” including “grants, scholarships, work-study funds, and loans.”

On the other hand, the College Scholarship Service (CSS) Profile, offered by The College Board (the same company that administers AP tests and the SAT), is used only by select private colleges and universities. It determines how the school distributes its own institutional scholarship and grant money to applicants and charges a small per-school filing fee.

Students can choose to fill out both forms when applying to college depending on the schools they’re looking at and what kind of financial aid they’re seeking. In fact, most schools that mandate the CSS Profile also mandate the FAFSA.

What Does Each Form Tell a College About Your Finances?

Obviously, each form asks for your family’s financial information — income, assets, tax returns, etc. — but how they collect and use this info differs by the form.

How the FAFSA Is Used

Completing the FAFSA is a relatively simple process; in fact, the FAFSA website claims it can be completed in just 12 minutes. However, gathering the necessary documents, which includes account balances and tax returns, may take slightly longer. But once it is completed, students will know if they qualify for grants, scholarships, work-study funds, and loans. Many schools also use the info collected on the FAFSA to determine if a student is eligible for further aid from the school.

The form collects information about a student’s and, when applicable, their parents’ income and assets. This information is used to calculate the Student Aid Index (SAI), a number colleges use when determining financial aid eligibility.

How Colleges Use the CSS Profile

On the other hand, the CSS Profile helps participating colleges award their own institutional financial aid, including grants and scholarships. These funds are separate from federal financial aid and are evaluated solely by the schools in question. It is also important to note that not every school uses the CSS Profile — see if the schools you’re applying to use the CSS profile here.

The CSS Profile often asks for more detailed financial information, such as home equity, medical expenses, private school tuition, and information about a noncustodial parent. While the FAFSA evaluates and rewards aid in the same way for each student, each individual school might determine a student’s eligibility for aid differently. For instance, the income cutoff for a school’s private scholarship might be significantly higher or lower than the cutoff for a federal grant.

Do You Need to Complete Both Forms?

The answer to this question depends on the schools to which you’re applying and the kind of aid you’re seeking. It’s usually never a bad idea to at least complete the FAFSA, especially since it’s free and relatively quick to complete.

If your school(s) use the CSS Profile, it’s worth asking if it’s necessary to complete or if the FAFSA is sufficient, since that’s an extra expense you could avoid in the college admissions process. And some schools have separate financial aid applications altogether, so it’s always worth clarifying before you apply.

Where Families Often Need Extra Guidance

For some families, completing financial aid forms is relatively straightforward. For others, the process can become more complicated when household circumstances change or additional documentation is required — below are some common situations that cause confusion when families complete financial aid applications. (As always, consult each school’s financial aid guidelines before submitting any information!)

Divorced or Separated Parents

Under current FAFSA rules, the parent responsible for providing the greater portion of the student's financial support is generally the parent whose information is required when the student's parents are divorced or separated, subject to the form's specific rules. This is not necessarily the parent with whom the student spends the most time.

The CSS Profile follows different procedures. Depending on the college, a noncustodial parent may need to submit a separate application providing financial information. Some institutions grant exceptions to this requirement in certain circumstances.

Changes in Family Income

Financial aid applications generally rely on tax information from a prior year. As a result, the income reported on a form may not reflect a family’s current financial circumstances, especially if parents have experienced a salary reduction and/or loss, job change, or medical expense.

Regardless of whether the family is completing the FAFSA, CSS Profile, or both, it’s a good idea to contact the financial aid office instead of simply replacing the info on the paperwork with the current salary estimates. Each school likely has a different process for evaluating this info, so it can get confusing if the numbers on the application differ from your federal paperwork.

Additional Documents and IDOC

Some colleges require financial aid applicants to submit additional documents after completing the FAFSA or CSS Profile, including but not limited to tax returns, W-2 forms, and business records. The College Board’s Institutional Documentation Service (IDOC) allows participating institutions to collect and review certain supporting documents through a centralized process, although it’s important to note that not every college uses IDOC and document requirements vary. That’s why it’s important to consistently check your application and financial aid portals so that you don’t miss any requests for additional documentation!

How to Plan Financial Aid Alongside Your College Applications

While students submit their college applications and financial aid applications separately — and, in the case of need-blind admissions, are reviewed and considered separately — you should still make a financial aid application plan alongside your college applications. Your financial aid situation can also significantly alter your college list and which schools are actually feasible for you to attend. Plus, you don’t want to miss out on the deadlines for applicable financial aid and scholarship opportunities!

Add Aid Requirements to Your College List

When students finalize their college list and start creating a plan for tackling their essays and activities list, it’s important to also create a list of any aid application requirements alongside the application requirements. Many parents take on the responsibility of aid applications since they’re usually more familiar with the family financial situation, but it’s important that everyone is aware of what needs to be submitted when. Many school-specific grants and scholarships might also require an additional essay or statement from the applicant.

International applicants should pay particular attention to these requirements, since their financial aid options and application procedures may differ from those of domestic students. It’s also important for international students to note when creating a college list which U.S. schools are need-aware, as many schools that are typically need-blind for U.S. students are often considering financial need for international applicants.

Consider Affordability Alongside Admissions Fit

As mentioned above, a school’s price tag can significantly alter a school’s place in a student’s college list. If it is unrealistic for a student to attend a certain school, even considering possible aid packages, then it’s not worth a student’s time and effort to apply. It’s always ideal to avoid student loan debt that could burden a student long after graduation.

Before ruling out a school, however, be sure to communicate with the aid office about what might be possible upon your potential acceptance — many schools will negotiate aid packages for students who have been admitted.

What to Do Before and After You Submit

Before submitting financial aid applications, families should gather the relevant tax and financial records, confirm the types of information required, and review each institution’s deadlines. After submission, students should save all confirmation records, monitor their financial aid and application portals, and respond promptly to requests for additional documentation.

They should also review financial aid offers carefully once admission decisions arrive, comparing grants, scholarships, work-study, loans, and the remaining out-of-pocket cost — and stay in contact with the financial aid office if you have any additional questions.

Frequently Asked Questions

Below are the answers to some questions that many students and their parents have about financial aid, the CSS Profile, the FAFSA, and more.

Can International Students Complete the CSS Profile?

Yes, international students can complete the CSS Profile if they are applying to participating colleges that use it to evaluate international applicants for institutional financial aid. However, international students generally cannot receive federal student aid through the FAFSA unless they meet the applicable eligible noncitizen requirements.

Is the CSS Profile Free for Some Families?

Yes, the College Board offers CSS Profile fee waivers to eligible students who meet its criteria, which is as follows:

  • Family adjusted gross income is up to $100,000,
  • the student qualified for an SAT fee waiver, or
  • the student is an orphan or ward of the court under the age of 24.

Per the College Board’s website: “CSS Profile for noncustodial parents living in the U.S. is free to submit for undergraduate students' noncustodial parents whose family adjusted gross income is up to $100,000.”

What If a College Requests More Documents?

If a college requests additional financial documentation, submit the requested materials by the stated deadline and follow the institution’s instructions. Some colleges use IDOC to collect supporting documents, while others have their own submission procedures. If you have any confusion, contact the financial aid office as soon as possible.

Conclusion

Financial aid can be a tricky part of the college admissions process, and understanding the difference between the FAFSA and the CSS Profile is an important step to making the most of your financial aid application. Make sure to stay ahead of deadlines, gather the proper documents, and follow each financial aid office’s instructions to guarantee an efficient college admissions process.

Looking for help planning your next steps in the college admissions process? Set up a free consultation with one of our experienced H&C admissions consultants today.

Recent Posts